We’ve had 43 Presidents in these United States. So far, all have been white men, though I expect that to change come January of next year.
They’ve varied in quality from exceptional (Washington, Lincoln, both Roosevelts), to mediocre (Carter, Grant), to really awful (Harding, Nixon). Most have served out at least one term. Some have gone back for seconds. Only one has served more than two.
People debate and discuss the relative merits of each President fairly often. There’s some that are everyone’s favorites and some that no one really likes. But then there’s the other groups. The ones that very highly overrated and ones that are very highly underrated.
To me the most overrated President in American history is John Kennedy. He wasn’t at all bad, and his handling of the Cuban Missle Crisis was genius. But really he didn’t accomplish too terribly much before he was assassinated. The fact that he was young, attractive and died so early have no doubt done much to convince the public he was better than he actually was. Had he lived, he would’ve likely been one of the best Presidents we’ve ever had, but he didn’t.
His real accomplishments, like the Cuban Missle Crisis, working on civil rights and pushing us towards the Moon cannot be ignored. But we can’t ignore the fact that, beyond those, he didn’t really do all that much for our country.
As for underrated, clearly the top choice there is James K Polk. Here’s a man who did much to make our country go from sea to shinning sea. He waged the Mexican-American War (which we’d been expected to lose), settled the boundry dispute with the UK over Canada, created the Department of the Interior, tried (and failed), to buy Cuba from Spain, and, unfortunately, fought hard to keep the institution of slavery alive.
Despite that last part, he did more than many to get our country up to the size it is now, and for that alone, he needs to be remembered more than he is. Sadly, due to a rather silly last name that’s not likely to happen.
So who do you folks think are the most overrated and underrated Presidents?
(photos stolen from Wikipedia!)



